Monday, February 29, 2016

Fifth and Sixth

Will you miss your chance to a fair trial in a criminal situation? The Sixth Amendment coincides with the Fifth Amendment when applying to the criminal system. Crawford helps us to understand that there are specific situations that the Sixth Amendment would pertain to as opposed to the Fifth Amendment. If there is not an understanding of Miranda rights and the justice system, we might confuse what rights can apply to criminal situation and miss an opportunity to be represented correctly.

To be clear the Sixth Amendment applies once the government has committed itself to the prosecution of the case (Crawford). According to Crawford, the timeframe of a case that happens when the criminal investigation is taking place is when the Fifth Amendment would apply. During a trial, the Sixth Amendment that is in place to ensure a criminal is provided with counsel applies. The first opportunity to use ones right to counsel happens during arrest when the arresting officer reads the Miranda rights. Although this is when your rights are explained, the Sixth Amendment will not apply. The Fifth Amendment is what is applying to this portion of the criminal investigation. Knowing this would help one to understand how the constitution applies to the rights of an individual.

The Sixth Amendment applies to critical stages, lineups, deliberate elicitation, and is crime specific. Depending on what stage the criminal process is at the present, the right to counsel can be determined by the judge. The crime that has been committed in conjunction to another crime will also determine if right to counsel should apply. Crawford explains how in particular cases we get examples of how a judge can determine if the right to counsel will apply. With the information that Crawford has given individuals are able to understand how the Sixth Amendment applies to cases.                                   



NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

Crawford, Kimberly A. "The Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel." July 2001. The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. Febuary 2016. <http://ez2.maricopa.edu/login?url=http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA77417465&v=2.1&u=mcc_smtn&it=r&p=EAIM&sw=w&asid=92b6e13e6d5efd659828bd761ba93fc0>.




1 comment:

  1. I also agree, that if the Miranda rights are not understood. It is easy to confuse what rights can apply to the situation. Which goes back to the issue of being misrepresented.

    _Cinthia Rios

    ReplyDelete