Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Reorganization

From past to present changes have been made in the state and federal judicial system to help defenders gain as much counsel as possible. This article from the National Legal Aid and Defender Association, gives a brief but detailed explanation of what changes have been made and how defenders are affected by these changes.

Although the Sixth amendment was established and reaffirmed many years ago, affirmation being in 1938, it was not until recently that states enforced it (National Legal Aid and Defender Association). In recent years, instead of looking for lawyers to offer services without fees to low income defenders, state have begun assigning these cases to attorneys that they employ. The establishment of state provided attorneys was not done until 1963, which are many years since the Sixth Amendment was established.
In the present time, not only did the Supreme Court apply the Sixth Amendment to all crimes with the Gideon case, but it also applies to minors (National Legal Aid and Defender Association). This was not previously established and had to be once indigent minor cases became an issue. The amendment enforcement on the juvenile and misdemeanor levels is new in the twentieth century.

In the present time, the right to counsel not only applies to critical portions of the trial like post arrest interrogation, preliminary hearings and plea negations. The right to counsel is also present during appeals and sentencing procedures. Regardless of the defendants being low income or not. Indigent defense is now more than present in federal cases along with state level cases due to various changes that have been made over the years. In an effort to keep things organized there is now an explanation on the standards for national, state and local levels to stick to concerning when the Sixth Amendment applies (National Legal Aid and Defender Association).
NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

National Legal Aid and Defender Association. "History of Right to Counsel." 2011. NLADA. Document. 8 March 2016. <http://www.nlada.org/About/About_HistoryDefender>.


Monday, March 7, 2016

Low Income Issues

Should financial status determine if the Sixth Amendment applies to your situation? I have to agree with Sloan, it does seem that it does when you think about exactly who is effected when public defense is appointed. When considering that taxpayers are responsible for footing the expense when a criminal is in custody and the legal representation, lower income individuals are the ones that suffer. A recent report from The Constitution Project’s bipartisan National Right to Counsel Committee shows that, without effective representation at a pretrial release hearing, all too often poor defendants remain locked in jail at great cost to themselves and their families, often losing jobs and homes (Sloan).
The financial burden of low-income individuals is felt and should not be because it takes the constitution rights away or delays them from being applied. Although most would feel this should not be a factor in how the constitution applies, it does. When a public defender is assigned to a case, it is often one of many that will not be fully reviewed due to lack of time. The attorney is not compensated adequately and yet still the amendment is supposed to be upheld. We all need to take into consideration the results that we expect out of this.
In lower income situations, the individual is usually trying to gain freedom. That mixed with the lack of attention to detail the case receives; sitting in custody is not the optimal result. We are all responsible for this issue with society (Sloan). In states like New York, the lack of attention to lower income individuals causes more output from taxpayers because it lacks structure.


NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited 
Sloan, Virginia. "Indigent defendants also deserve right to counsel." 30 January 2016. timesunion. Letters to the editor. 7 March 2016. <http://blog.timesunion.com/opinion/indigent-defendants-also-deserve-right-to-counsel/34404/>.


Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Drastic Measures

This is what happens when things get out of control. In the state of Massachusetts the judicial court in Hampden county was forced to release criminals due to lack of representation and lawsuits (Associated Press). Being appreciative to those that provide a public service would be a great way to avoid breaking the constitutional laws that have been established. Those that are financially unable to afford a lawyer use those provided by the court. 

In Hampden County, that leaves 110 county-staffed lawyers to service over 200,000 cases (Associated Press). The compensation and caseload was so high that lawsuits by two different groups where filed causing drastic changes to the cases. The issues in this state like others, has caused the lawyers to take measures in an effort to ensure quality. Although the right to counsel is a constitutional right, the treatment of such right needs to be beneficial and adequate. The Committee for Public Counsel Services was able to take action with the lawsuit that it filed on behalf of defendants that were not being served.

With the measures that were taken in Boston, defendants were released due to the shortage of public defenders. The stipulations of the release where that if there was no lawyer assigned within seven days of their hearing they would be released on bail (Associated Press). Within 45 days if a lawyer had not been assigned the case would be dismissed (Associated Press). With this action, being taken the need to have more lawyers was noticed by more than the judicial situation.

Although there are some states like Massachusetts and Louisiana that have actually taken action about the lack of lawyers available to defendants, it may be too little too late. When the situation involves releasing a criminal back into society it makes you question the intentions in the beginning.

NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

Associated Press. "Mass. Court: Lawyer Shortage Hurts Defendents." 28 July 2004. FOX News. Article. 2 March 2016. <http://www.foxnews.com/story/2004/07/28/mass-court-lawyer-shortage-hurts-defendants.html>.


Monday, February 29, 2016

Fifth and Sixth

Will you miss your chance to a fair trial in a criminal situation? The Sixth Amendment coincides with the Fifth Amendment when applying to the criminal system. Crawford helps us to understand that there are specific situations that the Sixth Amendment would pertain to as opposed to the Fifth Amendment. If there is not an understanding of Miranda rights and the justice system, we might confuse what rights can apply to criminal situation and miss an opportunity to be represented correctly.

To be clear the Sixth Amendment applies once the government has committed itself to the prosecution of the case (Crawford). According to Crawford, the timeframe of a case that happens when the criminal investigation is taking place is when the Fifth Amendment would apply. During a trial, the Sixth Amendment that is in place to ensure a criminal is provided with counsel applies. The first opportunity to use ones right to counsel happens during arrest when the arresting officer reads the Miranda rights. Although this is when your rights are explained, the Sixth Amendment will not apply. The Fifth Amendment is what is applying to this portion of the criminal investigation. Knowing this would help one to understand how the constitution applies to the rights of an individual.

The Sixth Amendment applies to critical stages, lineups, deliberate elicitation, and is crime specific. Depending on what stage the criminal process is at the present, the right to counsel can be determined by the judge. The crime that has been committed in conjunction to another crime will also determine if right to counsel should apply. Crawford explains how in particular cases we get examples of how a judge can determine if the right to counsel will apply. With the information that Crawford has given individuals are able to understand how the Sixth Amendment applies to cases.                                   



NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

Crawford, Kimberly A. "The Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel." July 2001. The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. Febuary 2016. <http://ez2.maricopa.edu/login?url=http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA77417465&v=2.1&u=mcc_smtn&it=r&p=EAIM&sw=w&asid=92b6e13e6d5efd659828bd761ba93fc0>.




Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Teamwork Maybe?

What if we all worked together? Each criminal is entitled to counsel and defense attorneys’ that work for the state must defend whomever they are given. With limited options what are the possibilities when the two unfortunate circumstances come together?
The Stanford Law School decided that they would provide counsel to inmates that had been given life sentences in an effort to eliminate the unfair trial situation in California. The project was directed by Michael Romano and was founded in 2006 (Wikipedia contributors). Being that the convicts where non-violent and mostly had ineffective assistance by counsel that was appointed by their Sixth Amendment, time and attention was important in this project. Being that court appointed counsel is not always able to respond timely and investigate the caseloads this was good opportunity to make corrections. The teams of two individual students are able to appeal the courts, request resentencing hearings and look at the cases of criminals that were convicted to life for non-violent crimes. This experience shows that even though there are many criminals and fewer attorneys in this situation there is some justice that can come out of the judicial system.
Another program that shows that even though criminals are convicted, they can have positive outcomes is the assistance that Carlos and Roby have shown fellow felons (Mooallem). In the article, You Just Got Out of Prison. Now what, they encourage the adjustments that must be made the first day of release from prison. Many individuals that had been involved in the Three Strikes Program needed help adjusting to coming out of prison after many years. These ex felons saw the void and filled it.
Working together the Three Strike Program from Stanford and the mission that Carlos and Roby have embarked on show what happens if these two situations work together in an effort to correct some unjust deeds that have already been committed.
NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

Mooallem, Jon. "You Just Got Out of Prison. Now What?" 19 July 2015. The New York Times Magazine. Article. 24 Febuary 2016. <http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/19/magazine/you-just-got-out-of-prison-now-what.html?_r=1>.
The Advocates' Society. Senior Council Forum . 24 Febury 2016. Document .
Wikipedia contributors. "Stanford Law School Three Strikes Project." 20 November 2013. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 25 Febuary 2016. <https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Stanford_Law_School_Three_Strikes_Project&oldid=582477345>.


Sunday, February 21, 2016

When is it too much?

How much is too much? When it comes to the amount of cases that a public defender can effectively handle the boundaries seem to have no limits. Recently the states attorney office in Louisiana had to make the decision not to accept cases. Being that the right to counsel is offered to all criminals because it is a right this type of decision does not seem just. Being that a serious offender’s case can take 47 hours of research and a misdemeanor can take 12 there has to be some way that when court appointed counsel is overloaded with cases, they can make them stop (Bunton). In the state of Louisiana, there is an issue with the caseload of the public defenders that they decided to control. The state defenders office decided that they would not be able to continue to take cases without being able to properly defend the criminals. The case that determined this was the case of a man that hired a private attorney over the court appointed lawyer and was able to get his charges dropped due to timely movement on his attorney part. The state saw that they were not able to do things like this and decided that there would be no choice but to limit the amount of cases they take from judges. The issue in the state of Louisiana and other states that have smaller budgets and many criminals is funding. There needs to be more incentive to take on the career of a court appointed attorney. There is limit budgeting for the different levels that are responsible for compensating these attorney’s yet the criminals continue to require their assistance. According to the article in The New York Times, the Louisiana court system is nothing more than a processing system and not a legal system (Bunton). When the rights that each citizens has come into play there would need to be more structure in the legal system.
NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited


Bunton, Derwyn. "When the Public Defender Says, "I Can't Help"." 19 Febuary 2016. The New York Times. 21 Febuary 2016.

Wednesday, February 17, 2016

Motivation


Image result for lawyers in court clip art
Do we ever take the time to consider what type of support is required to maintain the constitution that we live by in the United States? Many take for granted that if you happen to experience a criminal case in your lifetime, your country ensures you will have an attorney available to defend you. The treatment that the attorney is given just to ensure you receive a fair trial is questionable to say the least. The motives of the attorney would come to mind due to the brutal amount of time that is required to serve for various criminals. Some feel that there is a stereotype on public defenders because of the lack of recognition that is given to them (Weiss, pg.2). Being that caseloads are heavy and compensation may not be the best I would also question the reason this particular field has been chosen by an individual. In a criminal case, attorneys that are appointed to these cases defend the most horrendous acts. The struggle with understanding motives can become clearer when understanding that the attorney must defend the criminal. The attorney is responsible for understanding all the facts of the case along with knowing what the client’s plea is. The attorney would need to be able to put shape to the crime, which requires knowing all information from the accused prospective (Weiss pg.5). There is no explanation as to what exactly the motive is of a court appointed attorney. The presence and drive that they display is enough to not question the motives but be supportive as possible of the task they provide.


NiamBi Robinson

Works Cited

Weiss, Michael Scott. Public Defenders : Pragmatic And Political Motivations To Represent The Indigent. New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC, 2005. eBook Collection (EBSCOhost). Web. 17 Feb. 2016.