Should financial status determine if the Sixth Amendment
applies to your situation? I have to agree with Sloan, it does seem that it
does when you think about exactly who is effected when public defense is
appointed. When considering that taxpayers are responsible for footing the
expense when a criminal is in custody and the legal representation, lower
income individuals are the ones that suffer. A recent report from The
Constitution Project’s bipartisan National Right to Counsel Committee shows
that, without effective representation at a pretrial release hearing, all too
often poor defendants remain locked in jail at great cost to themselves and
their families, often losing jobs and homes (Sloan) .
The financial burden of low-income individuals is felt
and should not be because it takes the constitution rights away or delays them
from being applied. Although most would feel this should not be a factor in how
the constitution applies, it does. When a public defender is assigned to a case,
it is often one of many that will not be fully reviewed due to lack of time. The
attorney is not compensated adequately and yet still the amendment is supposed
to be upheld. We all need to take into consideration the results that we expect
out of this.
In lower income situations, the individual is usually
trying to gain freedom. That mixed with the lack of attention to detail the
case receives; sitting in custody is not the optimal result. We are all
responsible for this issue with society (Sloan) . In states like New
York, the lack of attention to lower income individuals causes more output from
taxpayers because it lacks structure.
NiamBi Robinson
Works Cited
Sloan, Virginia. "Indigent defendants also
deserve right to counsel." 30 January 2016. timesunion. Letters to
the editor. 7 March 2016.
<http://blog.timesunion.com/opinion/indigent-defendants-also-deserve-right-to-counsel/34404/>.
Hello NiamBi, I agree that public defenders not compensated enough for the load of cases that they receive. It is obvious that many cases are left to hang with no time to fully review the case and fight for the defendant. Sometimes the defendant was at the wrong place at the wrong time and sometimes the defendant actually deserves jail time. The defendant without financial ability to pay for private law services may end up serving undeserved time because of the lack of time the public defender has to review the case before trail.
ReplyDelete